Several Westhill High School lacrosse players attempted a hazing that failed the day before they abducted a teammate, according to WSYR-TV. Victims recognized the players during the April 23 prank, avoiding the incident without filing any complaints.

As two other crosstown rivals played a thrilling lacrosse game that went into overtime one night last week, some members of the Westhill High School boys’ varsity lacrosse team were in the stands hatching a plan.

All 11 students in New York turned themselves in to the Onondaga County Sheriff’s Office on April 30 after being given 48 hours to surrender.